diff --git a/client/src/main/java/ctbrec/ui/tabs/RecordingsTab.java b/client/src/main/java/ctbrec/ui/tabs/RecordingsTab.java
index f636d2ff..4b5eb1c5 100644
--- a/client/src/main/java/ctbrec/ui/tabs/RecordingsTab.java
+++ b/client/src/main/java/ctbrec/ui/tabs/RecordingsTab.java
@@ -413,13 +413,14 @@ public class RecordingsTab extends Tab implements TabSelectionListener, Shutdown
         JavaFxRecording first = recordings.get(0);
         var openInPlayer = new MenuItem("Open in Player");
         openInPlayer.setOnAction(e -> play(first));
-        if (first.getStatus() == FINISHED || Config.getInstance().getSettings().localRecording) {
-            contextMenu.getItems().add(openInPlayer);
-        } else if (first.getStatus() == RECORDING && !Config.getInstance().getSettings().localRecording) {
-            openInPlayer.setText("Open live stream");
-            openInPlayer.setOnAction(e -> play(first.getModel()));
+        if (first.getStatus() == RECORDING || first.getStatus() == FINISHED) {
             contextMenu.getItems().add(openInPlayer);
         }
+        if (first.getStatus() == RECORDING) {
+            var openLiveStream = new MenuItem("Open live stream");
+            openLiveStream.setOnAction(e -> play(first.getModel()));
+            contextMenu.getItems().add(openLiveStream);
+        }
 
         var openContactSheet = new MenuItem("Open contact sheet");
         openContactSheet.setOnAction(e -> openContactSheet(first));